The Clan leaders hold a separate meeting to send out a preliminary scouting patrol to scope out the new territories, but in Starlight, it is the same first meeting when Onewhisker interrupts Mudclaw.Mudclaw is said to be a kit in the nursery when Tallstar became leader, but in Tallstar's Revenge, he is shown as a warrior when Tallstar is going to receive his nine lives.Onewhisker is depicted with the scar behind his ear, despite not receiving it until he is Onestar.Feathertail mistakenly refers to Hawkfrost and Mothwing by their apprentice names when they are sleeping in the warriors' den, and Feathertail's dream coincides with the prologue of Midnight when Hawkfrost and Mothwing are already warriors.Hawkfrost is shown with a very faint white underside instead of a full white belly.Throughout the manga novel, cats are shown to have either three or four toes.Ruby's foreleg is miscolored as black-and-white.
